In this guide, we’ll take a look at the best sandwich toasters. We’ve compared design, power, ease of cleaning and cost to give you our top recommendations.

What Is The Best Sandwich Toasters?

IMAGE RECOMMENDED PRODUCTSPRODUCT FEATURES
  • Best versatile sandwich toaster
  • Three interchangeable grill plates
  • Quality non-stick coating
  • Best non-stick sandwich toaster
  • Deep fill cooking plates
  • Cool touch housing
  • Best compact sandwich toaster
  • Deep cooking plates
  • Integral cord storage
  • Best design sandwich toaster
  • Built-in drip tray
  • Adjustable temperature gauge
  • Best easy storage sandwich toaster
  • Extra deep plates
  • Cord storage in base
  • Best professional sandwich toaster
  • Thermostat control with two pilot lights
  • Skid-resistant feet

More Detailed Sandwich Toaster Reviews

Salter EK2143 Sandwich Toaster

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Best versatile sandwich toaster
  • Three interchangeable grill plates
  • Quality non-stick coating
OUR RATING
PRICE
CHECK PRICE →

Salter EK2143 Sandwich Toaster Review

This versatile sandwich toaster comes with interchangeable top and bottom grill plates so as well as toasted sandwiches, you can also make waffles and paninis. Quality non-stick coating means a perfectly cooked snack and minimal time spent washing up.

The different plates are easy to fit. They are also extra large for thicker results and the 900W power means you won’t have to wait too long either.

Operation is easy with two light indicators for power on and ‘ready’, a locking catch and cool touch handles. This Salter sandwich toaster is one kitchen accessory you won’t want to be without.

Pros

  • Cook supersized waffles, sandwiches and paninis, much thicker and deeper than competing products
  • Simple to operate
  • Easy storage, nice and compact
  • Recipes available on the Salter website

Cons

  • 900W power is not very generous so cooking time is longer for items with lots of filling

Tower 3-in-1 Sandwich Toaster

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Best non-stick sandwich toaster
  • Deep fill cooking plates
  • Cool touch housing
OUR RATING
PRICE
CHECK PRICE →

Tower 3-in-1 Sandwich Toaster Review

Upgrade your family’s snacks with this stylish and multi-functional sandwich toaster from Tower. Three extra-deep plates allow you to swap from paninis to waffles to good old fashioned sandwiches with ease, providing tasty meal options for the whole household.

The ceramic plates require hardly any oil, so cooking is healthier and cleaning up, quick and easy. Two lights indicate power and when your meal is ready.

Cool touch housing means this sandwich toaster is safe to handle whilst serving. Non-slip feet will keep the unit secure on your countertop whilst cooking is in process.

Pros

  • Plates heat up evenly and cook well
  • Grill plates are simple to change
  • Deep fill means less mess and spills

Cons

  • No heating adjustment to vary the temperature
  • Cooking time is slow

Global Gourmet by Sensiohome Sandwich Toaster

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Best compact sandwich toaster
  • Deep cooking plates
  • Integral cord storage
OUR RATING
PRICE
CHECK PRICE →

Global Gourmet by Sensiohome Sandwich Toaster Review

Deep cooking plates provide a more generous fill for your favourite snack or meal. Non-stick coating means that delivery is quick and easy. A wipe with a damp cloth is all you need to do after cooking and the toaster is ready for next time.

Safety is a priority for this brand with a power ready indicator, cool touch handle and non-slip feet. The body of the unit is heat resistant and insulated.

Compact and space-saving, this sandwich toaster stores flat with cord storage under the housing so will slot away in a cupboard when not in use. Perfectly portable, this Sensiohome sandwich toaster is the ideal choice for student kitchens, offices and caravans.

 

Pros

  • Makes delicious deep fill toasties in minutes
  • Power on and ready to cook indicator lights
  • Easy clean, just wipe with a damp cloth
  • Seals the bread edges properly and doesn’t squash the filling

Cons

  • Lengthy warm up time
  • Plates are not removable to clean

Netta Sandwich Toaster

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Best design sandwich toaster
  • Built-in drip tray
  • Adjustable temperature gauge
OUR RATING
PRICE
CHECK PRICE →

Netta Sandwich Toaster Review

Create delicious and varied sandwiches for the family, perfect as a tasty snack or meal plus you can also warm crumpets, pitta bread and teacakes in this stylish toaster.

The ridged surface on the grill plates encourages fat to drain away to the built-in drip tray. A hinged lid accommodates different depths of sandwich filling. The adjustable temperature gauge allows you to choose just the right amount of ‘toast’ for your snack.

Cool touch handles keep all the family safe whilst the modern design in sleek black and silver is a stylish addition to any kitchen countertop.

Pros

  • Hinged lid opens to horizontal providing lots more cooking options
  • Drip tray for no mess
  • Adjustable temperature offers more cooking control

Cons

  • Lower on power than alternative toasters so cooking time is longer
  • Grill plates cannot be removed for a thorough clean

Andrew James Sandwich Toaster

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Best easy storage sandwich toaster
  • Extra deep plates
  • Cord storage in base
OUR RATING
PRICE
CHECK PRICE →

Andrew James Sandwich Toaster Review

If you like your sandwiches packed with filling, then this is the toaster for you. Extra deep 26mm plates mean there is lots of room and the large size creates perfectly sealed triangles which really look the part, perfect for guests.

Because the plates are large on this model, it is possible to create a perfect seal so not only does your sandwich look good but there is no mess on the grill plates. A secure lock applies even pressure for a consistent toast and there is an indicator light for when the food is ready.

Cord housing in the base plus the design of this toaster allows you to store it in an upright position so it is incredibly space saving for compact kitchens.

Pros

  • Works with any type of bread
  • Seals well and does not leak
  • Clear instructions plus tasty recipes

Cons

  • No automatic switch off, needs to be turned off at the wall so it’s easy to forget
  • Grill plates are not removable
  • Only works with large bread slices

MasterChef Sandwich Toaster

FEATURES RATING PRICE
FEATURES
  • Best professional sandwich toaster
  • Thermostat control with two pilot lights
  • Skid-resistant feet
OUR RATING
PRICE
CHECK PRICE →

MasterChef Sandwich Toaster Review

This is a branded product from fans of the MasterChef television series, but you certainly won’t feel the heat in the kitchen when you use this sandwich toaster to make a tasty treat.

Thermostat-controlled indicator lights accommodate all the family’s preferences. The stainless-steel housing is stylish and cool to the touch. A handy indicator light lets you know when the sandwich is ready.

Non-stick coating makes for an easy clean and this sandwich toaster can be stored upright or flat making it perfect for tight spaces.

Pros

  • Patterned plate for perfect croque monsieur toasties
  • Ideal fit for large bread slices
  • Quick to warm up

Cons

  • No heat controls
  • Filling escapes on the unsealed side
  • Non-removable toasting plates

Sandwich Toaster Buying Guide

Whether it’s for a lunchtime bite, or if you’re making breakfast for someone special, a sandwich press can be a real game changer. But what should you look for when buying one? Here’s a few tips:

Sandwich capacity

Sandwich presses with deep filling capabilities really do open up your options, it levels up your sandwiches from a tasty-toastie, to a delicious overstuffed hot meal. Also, look for presses with interchangeable plates, this will give you more choices and capacity.

Non-Stick

This is essential, unless you enjoy scraping off burnt cheese from your appliances. Look for the all important ‘non-stick’ mentioned, even better if your prospective sandwich press has a specialised coating like cerastone, as this is less likely to scratch off.

Dishwasher-safe removable plates

As with the non-stick factor, having removable plates and being dishwasher-safe takes out the worry when cleaning, just pop them out, load in the dishwasher and go about your day.

Ease of cleaning

This cannot be stated enough. It’s not just about cleaning the outside or plates of your sandwich press. Look for units that will wipe down easily and not leave behind crusty bits that will be smushed into the next sandwich. Sharp corners, hard to clean lips, and tricky crevices are all problem areas, try to avoid these.

FAQ

How to use a sandwich toaster?

This couldn’t be easier. Preheat your sandwich press, place the first slice of bread into position, load your favourite toppings on that. When you’re satisfied with your creation place the second piece of bread on top, and close the lid.

There’s usually a latch that will click into place to help keep pressure on your sandwich so that it heats all the way through. After a few minutes, or if there’s an indicator light that goes on/off, your sandwich will be ready. Just lift the lid and with a wooden or plastic scraper lift the sandwich out.

Before you dive in, remember: the inside of your sandwich will be VERY hot, so be careful!

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

See More Helpful Product Reviews

Search
Scroll to Top